2 Wagon Lane, Brewster, NY 10509 - Luxury Fire Island Homes

$339,900

2 Wagon Ln is a single family home offering 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, approximately 1,088 square feet, and a lot of about 22,651 square feet, giving buyers a stronger combination of house and land than many smaller homes in the area. Built in 1945, the property offers the kind of… Read More setup that appeals to buyers looking for a Brewster NY home with usable outdoor space, a practical footprint, and room to improve over time instead of paying a premium for someone else’s finishes. Hardwood flooring is already in place, and the home has a straightforward layout that can work well for everyday living, a downsizing move, a second home, or a buyer looking for a value add opportunity in Putnam County. In addition to the main living area, the home also includes finished attic and finished basement space that expands the way the property can function, whether for storage, hobbies, workspace, overflow living, or other flexible use depending on a buyer’s needs. The basement area also includes a washer and dryer area, and the property is improved with two sheds that add even more exterior utility for tools, equipment, or general storage. The kitchen was updated around 10 years ago, the roof is approximately 12 years old with no known roof issues reported, and the home is served by septic and well. Oil heat system is present, and hot water type was not confirmed from the available records or photos. The main improvement path appears to center on bathroom work, interior cosmetic updates, and general modernization, making this a strong fit for a buyer who wants a home with a solid starting point and the ability to update at their own pace. There is no central air, so buyers should plan around their preferred cooling solution. The lot size is another part of the appeal here, especially for buyers searching for a Brewster property with more breathing room, outdoor flexibility, and a setting that offers more than just the house itself. For buyers searching online for a Brewster NY home with land, a Putnam County fixer upper, a single family home with hardwood floors, a house with finished attic and basement, or a property with septic and well in the Brewster or Carmel area, this listing checks several of the features that continue to draw interest. No HOA. Rental restrictions reported as no. SOME PHOTOS HAVE BEEN VIRTUALLY EDITED. Read Less

Listing Courtesy of Greene Realty Group, 860-560-1006.

Listing Snapshot

Days Online

Last Updated

Apr 5, 2026

Property Type

Single Family Residence

Beds

Full Baths

Square Ft.

1,088

Year Built

1945

Property Tax

$8,373

MLS Number

976403

Additional Details

Utilities

Utilities: "None", Sewer: "Septic Tank", Water Source: "Private"

Appliances & Equipment

Description: "Dishwasher", "Disposal", "Dryer", "Electric Range", "Refrigerator", "Washer", "Oil Water Heater"

Basement

Description: "Full"

Building

Area: 1088, Architecture: "Cottage", Construction Materials: "Other", Year Built: 1945

Cooling

Details: "None"

Exterior Features

Patio Features: "Patio"

Floors

Flooring: "Carpet", "Hardwood", "Tile"

Heating

Heating: "None"

Laundry

Description: "In Basement"

Lot

Features: "Back Yard", "Front Yard", "Paved", "Sloped", "Wooded", Acres: 0.5

Find The Perfect Home

'VIP' Listing Search

Whenever a listing hits the market that matches your criteria you will be immediately notified.

Join The List

Mortgage Calculator

Selling price

Down payment

Term (years)

Interest rate (%)

Monthly Payment

Test

2 Wagon Lane

'VIP' Listing Search

Schools In The Area

Similar Listings

Find My Dream Home

1. Neighborhoods

2. Home Type

3. Send

Be the first to know about new sales and rental listings, last-minute deals, market updates, and community events.

Luxury Fire Island Homes

Tools

About

Real Estate