Sell Your Home For MORE MONEY!

With over 9,000 Buyers in our database your home may already be sold. Count on Luxury Fire Island Homes to sell your home Fast and for Top Dollar.

Click here to receive new listings

Find Your Fire Island Home. Tour It. Own It.

Click here to be the first to receive new rental and sales listings

Find out what selling options are available for your home

2024 Fire Island Summer Events

Fire Island Homeowner Paint and Sip Nights 🍸
Thursday, July 11th, 2024 Starting at 6pm & Thursday, August 8th, 2024 Starting at 6pm

Fire Island Homeowner Paint and Sip Nights 🍸

Renter’s Bagel breakfast 🥯
Luxury Fire Island Homes - Ocean Bay Park Office 63 E. Bayview Avenue in Ocean Bay Park (Next to Schooners)

Renter’s Bagel breakfast 🥯

East End Art 🎨
Unleash your creativity while enjoying a relaxing atmosphere with fellow homeowners. This is a FREE event!

East End Art 🎨

Art in the Park 🖼️
Fire Island Homeowners

Art in the Park 🖼️

Featured Rental

Take a look at our Featured Rentals

For Rent $7,000/week
OB343D
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 2 Baths 9 Sleeps
Rental $15,000/week
SC15S
Summer Club, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 3 Baths 10 Sleeps
For Rent $5,500/week
OB612BB
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 2 Baths 10 Sleeps
Beach-Block $7,000/week
OB993SV
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
3 Beds 2 Baths 6 Sleeps
For Rent $5,450/week
OB296C
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 2 Baths 8 Sleeps
Beach-Block $3,700/week
OBP47EBA
Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island, NY
2 Beds 1.5 Baths 6 Sleeps
Beachfront $4,000/week
OBP49EBA
Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island, NY
2 Beds 1.5 Baths 6 Sleeps
Weekly Rental $6,500/month
OB898E
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
5 Beds 2 Baths 10 Sleeps
For Rent $11,000/week
S53C
Seaview, Fire Island, NY
5 Beds 2.5 Baths 11 Sleeps
Bayfront $25,000/month
OBP71EB
Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island, NY
3 Beds 2 Baths 6 Sleeps
Weekly Rental $10,780/week
S81B
Seaview, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 2.5 Baths 10 Sleeps
For Rent $6,300/week
OBP8O
Ocean Bay Park, NY
3 Beds 2 Baths 9 Sleeps
Beach-Block $7,000/week
OB820E
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
5 Beds 2 Baths 11 Sleeps
For Rent $30,000
S5A
Seaview, NY
3 Beds 1 Baths
For Rent $5,900
OB-890r
Ocean Beach, NY
3 Beds 1 Baths 1 Half Baths
For Rent $8,500
SC33S
Summer Club, NY
3 Beds 4 Baths 11 Sleeps
For Rent $8,800
OB499BB
Ocean Beach, NY
5 Beds 2 Full Baths
For Rent $9,500 / 6 Night Rental
CE50C
Corneille Estate, NY
4 Beds 3 Full Baths 12 Sleeps
For Rent $10,000 weekly (2024)
110 Ocean Rd
Ocean Beach, NY
5 Beds 1 Full Baths 2 Half Baths
For Rent $15,000
Ocean Beach, NY
5 Beds 3 Baths

Featured Homes

Take a look at our Featured Homes

Coming Soon $2,000,000
29 East Bayview Avenue
Ocean Bay Park, NY
3 Beds 2 Baths 1,296 SqFt.
Exclusive $1,150,000
106 Ocean Road
Ocean Beach, NY
Exclusive $1,700,000
657 Ocean Breeze Walk
Ocean Beach, NY
4 Beds 2 Baths ~1,800 SqFt.
Exclusive $2,150,000
38 Homesite Avenue
Seaview, NY
4 Beds 1.5 Baths

Recently Sold

Take a look at our Featured Homes

$985,000
140 Bungalow Walk
Ocean Beach, NY
4,000 SqFt. 3 Beds 1.5 Baths
$896,000
664 Ocean Breeze Walk
Ocean Beach, NY
3 Beds 2 Baths
$960,000
677 Ocean Breeze
Ocean Beach, NY
3 Beds 2 Baths
$900,000
890 Evergreen Ave
Ocean Beach, NY
3 Beds 1.5 Baths
$1,100,000
5 Cayuga St
Ocean Bay Park, NY
5 Beds 1.5 Baths
$1,590,000
639 Ocean Breeze Walk
Ocean Beach, NY
4 Beds 3 Baths ~2,000 SqFt.
$775,000
306 Cottage Walk
Ocean Beach, NY
3+DEN Beds 1 Baths
$40,000
OB306C
Ocean Beach, NY
3+DEN Beds 1.5 Baths 10 Sleeps
$2,950,000
29 Ivy Avenue
Seaview, NY
4 Beds 3.5 Baths
$1,950,000
844 Evergreen Walk
Ocean Beach, NY
7 Beds 3 Baths 2,000 SqFt.
$875,000
15 Cayuga
Ocean Bay Park, NY
3 Beds 1.5 Beds
$1,050,000
69 Walnut Walk
Fair Harbor, NY
3 Beds 1.5 Baths 1,000+ SqFt.

How we can help

Sell

conversation

Your Why

We take the time to understand why you’re selling your home to come up with a home-selling strategy that meets your needs.

pricing

Value Your Home

We find out what your home is worth, and offer insight on how to get TOP DOLLAR for your home.

first

Assess Your Sell

We evaluate and assess any issues with your home, and we make it ready to be someone else’s dream home.

marketing

We have the Buyers

We help you find serious, qualified buyers. With 9,000 Buyers in our database, we may already have sold your home.

Instant Home Evaluation

Buy

Vip

Discover Market Finds

We seek out relevant houses for sale that you may not be able to discover on your own.

house

Seek Best Values

We negotiate the best home values in the locations that suit your home buying needs.

Icon placeholder a1

Expertise

With over 60 years of combined experience in Fire Island real estate, you will be educated and empowered throughout the home buying process.

rating

Get Real Results

You get an experienced team and a proven track record.

See All Properties

We Are Hiring!

Find out more!

Search by Area

Find out more information about areas we service

View All Areas

About

Luxury Fire
Island Homes

Fire Island Sales

Fire Island Rentals 

Call or Text us 24/7 at (631) 570-8942 

We are local!

Luxury Fire Island Homes, formerly known as Fire Island Homes, is a full-service real estate brokerage located in Fire Island, NY. We offer residential Fire Island home sales, commercial sales and leases, and Fire Island vacation rentals. Laura and Brian Smith, Fire Island residents, ran Fire Island Homes for over 20 years. They merged with Sydney and Susan McCoy, owners of Your Home Sold Guaranteed Realty Services, a residential real estate brokerage located in Long Island, NY. The Smith and McCoy family have combined forces - resulting in the largest real estate brokerage in Fire Island. With thousands of buyers in their databases, 60 years of combined real estate experience in Long Island and Fire Island,  innovative marketing approaches, and value-driven ideals, Luxury Fire Island Homes is your one-stop shop for all your real estate needs - whether that is Fire Island Sales, Fire Island Rentals, or Fire Island Commercial Real Estate.  

Contact Us

Team

Meet the Fire Island Team

More Details

Susan McCoy

Owner

More Details

Sydney McCoy

Broker/Owner

More Details

Brian Smith

Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker

More Details

Tara Fishman

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

More Details

Ellen McCaffery

Administration

More Details

Kyle Ignatius Deriada

Client Success

More Details

Deepak Kumar

Design and Marketing Lead

More Details

Dough Roach

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

More Details

Nancy Scar

Real Estate Salesperson

View All Team Members
quotation

What Our Customers Are Saying

"What an incredibly wonderful business model they have here. Not only do they have all the real estate listings and very knowledgeable agents they have truly embraced the rich and vibrant artist comm… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
Devora Lans
View review on Google
"My experience with Luxury Fire Island Homes has been nothing short of outstanding. From the quality or service to the condition of the homes which the company provides, every aspect of this organizati… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
J W
View review on Google
"I recently hired Sydney Mccoy and Sebastian with Luxury Fire Island Homes to manage my property in Ocean Bay Park. I was extremely impressed with their track record of 5Star reviews and happy renters…… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
Santiago Dipilla
View review on Google
"I think the world of Sydney. She is the type of Realtor you want on your side. She brings a fresh, 21st-century style of knowledge, technology, marketing, and energy. I challenge anyone to match her a… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
Anthony Reese
View review on Google
"I've worked personally with Sydney and Sue and could not praise their dynamic, the relationships they build with their clients and their drive to help others enough. All the agents here are so kind an… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
Laur.a
View review on Google
"Sydney McCoy of Luxury Fire Island Homes is sharp, smart, friendly, outgoing and not only had her eyes peeled for every detail but put up with all my questions and notes...and I can be very annoying! … Read MoreRead Less
Photo
John Ordover
View review on Google
"Working with Sydney, Sue, and the team at Luxury Fire Island Homes was an extraordinary experience that exceeded all our expectations. From the moment we engaged their services, it was clear that they… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
Lexi Paleo
View review on Google
"After my listing expired with another local agent, I was disheartened and puzzled as to why my home wasn't attracting buyers. Skepticism clouded my thoughts about entrusting another agent. However, me… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
Alexa Van Nostrand
View review on Google
"What truly impressed us with working with Luxury Fire Island Homes was their ability to deliver results beyond our expectations. Despite being told our house would sell in a month, they managed to sec… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
Daniella Culkin
View review on Google
"Working with Sydney and Sue at Luxury Fire Island Homes was fantastic. Their top-notch service and constant communication made the selling process stress-free. They were always available to address an… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
Brayden Keller
View review on Google

Latest Stories

Stay updated with latest news and stories about Fire Island real estate.

View All Articles

Luxury Fire Island Homes - Luxury Fire Island Vacation Rentals and Sales - Celebrates Grand Opening in Ocean Bay Park

Ocean Bay Park, NY - Luxury Fire Island Homes is thrilled to announce the grand opening of its newes…

A Guide to Fire Island's Sunken Forest

Fire Island's Sunken Forest is a maritime holly forest situated behind well-established sand dunes…

Fire Island Community Spotlight | Fair Harbor

Located just a few miles across the Great South Bay (and 50 miles east of NYC), The Fire Island comm…