Sell Your Home For MORE MONEY!

With over 9,000 Buyers in our database your home may already be sold. Count on Luxury Fire Island Homes to sell your home Fast and for Top Dollar.

Click here to receive new listings

Fire Island Real Estate

Click here to be the first to receive new rental and sales listings

Find out what selling options are available for your home

2024 Fire Island Summer Events

Fire Island Homeowner Paint and Sip Nights 🍸

Fire Island Homeowner Paint and Sip Nights 🍸

Renter’s Bagel breakfast 🥯

Renter’s Bagel breakfast 🥯

East End Art 🎨

East End Art 🎨

Art in the Park 🖼️

Art in the Park 🖼️

Fire Island Rentals

Take a look at our Featured Rentals

$9,000/Week
OB207W
Ocean Beach, NY
4 Beds 2.5 Baths
$9,000/Week
OB657OB
Ocean Beach, NY
4 Beds 2 Baths
$13,000/Week
S28A
Seaview, NY
4 Beds 2 Baths
$10,000/Week
OBP5E
Ocean Bay Park, NY
4 Beds 2 Baths
$15,250/Week
OBP35H
Ocean Bay Park, NY
4 Beds 4.5 Baths
$7,000/week
S24B
Seaview, Fire Island, NY
3 Beds 2 Baths 8 Sleeps
$11,500/week
OB333S
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 3 Baths 13 Sleeps
$4,000/week
OB177W
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
3 Beds 1 Baths 6 Sleeps
$9,000 PER WEEK
OB639OB
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 3 Baths 12+ Sleeps
$32,500
OBP6M
Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island, NY
2 Beds 1 Baths 4 Sleeps
$13,500/week
OB109B
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 3 Baths 10 Sleeps
$7,500/week
OB337D
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 2 Baths 8 Sleeps
$10,000/week
S19C
Seaview, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 2 Full Baths 1 Half Baths
$4,500/week
OB917E
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
3 Beds 1 Full Baths 1 Half Baths
$6,800/week
OB740OB
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 2 Baths 10 Sleeps
$7,000/week
OB343D
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 2 Baths 9 Sleeps
$15,000/week
SC15S
Summer Club, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 3 Baths 10 Sleeps
$5,500/week
OB612BB
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 2 Baths 10 Sleeps
$7,000/week
OB993SV
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
3 Beds 2 Baths 6 Sleeps
$5,450/week
OB296C
Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY
4 Beds 2 Baths 8 Sleeps

Fire Island Homes For Sale

Take a look at our Featured Homes

$1,500,000
17 Superior Street
Ocean Bay Park, NY
2 Beds 1 Baths 684 SqFt.
$2,150,000
38 Homesite Avenue
Seaview, NY
4 Beds 1.5 Baths

How we can help

Sell

conversation

Your Why

We take the time to understand why you’re selling your home to come up with a home-selling strategy that meets your needs.

pricing

Value Your Home

We find out what your home is worth, and offer insight on how to get TOP DOLLAR for your home.

first

Assess Your Sell

We evaluate and assess any issues with your home, and we make it ready to be someone else’s dream home.

marketing

We have the Buyers

We help you find serious, qualified buyers. With 9,000 Buyers in our database, we may already have sold your home.

Instant Home Evaluation

Buy

Vip

Discover Market Finds

We seek out relevant houses for sale that you may not be able to discover on your own.

house

Seek Best Values

We negotiate the best home values in the locations that suit your home buying needs.

Icon placeholder a1

Expertise

With over 60 years of combined experience in Fire Island real estate, you will be educated and empowered throughout the home buying process.

rating

Get Real Results

You get an experienced team and a proven track record.

See All Properties

We Are Hiring!

Find out more!

Search by Area

Find out more information about areas we service

View All Areas

About

Luxury Fire
Island Homes

Fire Island Sales

Fire Island Rentals 

Call or Text us 24/7 at (631) 570-8942 

We are local!

Luxury Fire Island Homes, formerly known as Fire Island Homes, is a full-service real estate brokerage located in Fire Island, NY. We offer residential Fire Island home sales, commercial sales and leases, and Fire Island vacation rentals. Laura and Brian Smith, Fire Island residents, ran Fire Island Homes for over 20 years. They merged with Sydney and Susan McCoy, owners of Your Home Sold Guaranteed Realty Services, a residential real estate brokerage located in Long Island, NY. The Smith and McCoy family have combined forces - resulting in the largest real estate brokerage in Fire Island. With thousands of buyers in their databases, 60 years of combined real estate experience in Long Island and Fire Island,  innovative marketing approaches, and value-driven ideals, Luxury Fire Island Homes is your one-stop shop for all your real estate needs - whether that is Fire Island Sales, Fire Island Rentals, or Fire Island Commercial Real Estate.  

Contact Us

Team

Meet the Fire Island Team

More Details

Susan McCoy

Owner

More Details

Sydney McCoy

Broker/Owner

More Details

Dough Roach

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

More Details

Jeffrey Cluckey

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

More Details

Brett Brubaker

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

More Details

Brian Smith

Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker

More Details

Tara Fishman

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

More Details

Sebastian Gamboa

Property Manager

More Details

Kyle Ignatius Deriada

Client Success

More Details

Ellen McCaffery

Administration

More Details

Deepak Kumar

Design and Marketing Lead

More Details

Nancy Scar

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

View All Team Members
quotation

What Our Customers Are Saying

"Rented from Luxury FI Homes for a week this past summer and it was wonderful! The house was beautiful and comfortable, and the customer service was helpful. Would definitely rent from them again!"
Photo
Alana Rosenberg
View review on Google
"Great house, great host!!"
Photo
doug d
View review on Google
"If you're looking to buy or rent a home this is hands down the best place. The owner Sydney is so nice and welcoming, she will go above and beyond to help you find exactly what you are looking for! Th… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
John Amini
View review on Google
"The lovely ladies at Luxury Fire Island Homes are rock stars! And they sure know how to throw a party! They all encouraged me to show my handmade jewelry at their new East End Gallery last Thurs nite… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
Beth Kahn Sugarman
View review on Google
"This is our third season with Brian, and he always goes above and beyond. Brian was excellent, he walked me thru the first time rental process. He gave us door to door help, showed us what we needed t… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
Lynne Fontano Alba
View review on Google
"Great environment, professional and nice people. They care about their clients and understood my needs. Quick to respond and very attentive, I really can’t say enough good things."
Photo
Mary McGeever
View review on Google
"The house was Amazing... all the amenities were top notch.. view awesome...convenience of town and resturants and stores Brian Smith of fire island luxury homes was an excellent person of contact when… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
Tom Hardgrove
View review on Google
"The house was great. We had a fantastic time and would definitely book here again in the future. We have worked with Brian for several years now and have not been disappointed in his professionalism a… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
K M
View review on Google
"Brian at Fire Island Homes is my go-to guy for great rentals on Fire Island. He always exceeds expectations and ensures our entire stay is wonderful."
Photo
Jennifer Rommel
View review on Google
"What an incredibly wonderful business model they have here. Not only do they have all the real estate listings and very knowledgeable agents they have truly embraced the rich and vibrant artist comm… Read MoreRead Less
Photo
Devora Lans
View review on Google

Latest Stories

Stay updated with latest news and stories about Fire Island real estate.

View All Articles

Fire Island’s Role in LGBTQ+ Art and Culture

For decades, Fire Island has been a sanctuary for LGBTQ+ artists, writers, and performers, fostering…

The Ghost Stories of Fire Island: Legends That Still Haunt Us Today

Fire Island is known for its sun-soaked beaches, charming boardwalks, and vibrant nightlife—but when…

Ferries, Bikes & Boats: Getting Around Fire Island Like a Pro

Fire Island’s unique charm comes from its car-free lifestyle, making transportation an adventure in…