Amazing Success Stories
“From sunrise to sunset this was one of the best family vacations we’ve ever had! Thank you Brett and Jeff for all the help. Your care and expertise made this trip extra special!”
“We had an absolutely wonderful experience, the entire process was seamless from beginning to end. The home itself was beautiful—immaculately clean, thoughtfully designed, and exceptionally well equipped. It truly felt like every detail had been considered to make guests comfortable. What really set this experience apart, however, was the level of service. Before we even arrived, Jeff and Brett were in constant communication and, after heavy rains had caused flooding on the island, they met us at the ferry with two golf carts to help transport our luggage. It was such a thoughtful gesture and made our arrival effortless. Throughout our stay they were incredibly responsive and proactive. Whether answering questions, arranging maintenance after the storm, or quickly replacing an empty propane tank, everything was handled promptly and with genuine kindness. They never made us feel like we were imposing. The moment that really exceeded expectations came after we checked out. We accidentally left behind a bag of clothes, and they had it delivered. That level of care is rare. Jeff and Brett clearly take tremendous pride in their properties and the experience they provide their guests. Their professionalism, responsiveness, and hospitality made our vacation even more enjoyable. We would not hesitate to rent from them again and recommend them without reservation.”
“Great spot close to beach. Jeffrey our realtor was fantastic!”
“Although ultimately there was no availability in the community we wanted because of our late ask- Shelly was a great communicator and super responsive!”
“We loved staying with Jeff and Brett in Ocean Bay Park last year! They were incredible hosts who met us right when we arrived and took care of everything. We’re so excited to book with them again for this year’s vacation”
“Working with Luxury Fire Island Homes was an amazing experience from start to finish. They truly understand Fire Island - not just the market, but the lifestyle, the neighborhoods, and what actually matters when buying or renting here. The team was incredibly responsive, organized, and honest throughout the entire process. Every question was answered quickly, and we always felt supported and informed. They made what could have been a stressful experience feel easy and even enjoyable. If you’re looking for a team that combines deep local knowledge with professionalism and genuine care, Luxury Fire Island Homes is the way to go.”
“Rented from Luxury FI Homes for a week this past summer and it was wonderful! The house was beautiful and comfortable, and the customer service was helpful. Would definitely rent from them again!”
“Great house, great host!!”
“If you're looking to buy or rent a home this is hands down the best place. The owner Sydney is so nice and welcoming, she will go above and beyond to help you find exactly what you are looking for! The office has a great vibe to it and they have house listings in all of the towns in Fireisland which makes it really convenient. Highly recommended!”
“This is our third season with Brian, and he always goes above and beyond. Brian was excellent, he walked me thru the first time rental process. He gave us door to door help, showed us what we needed to know and was there to answer any questions. There were not many surprises along the way.”