Amazing Success Stories

“Sydney McCoy of Luxury Fire Island Homes is sharp, smart, friendly, outgoing and not only had her eyes peeled for every detail but put up with all my questions and notes...and I can be very annoying! LOL. You couldn't possibly do better with anyone.”

“Working with Sydney, Sue, and the team at Luxury Fire Island Homes was an extraordinary experience that exceeded all our expectations. From the moment we engaged their services, it was clear that they were dedicated to providing unparalleled service and achieving outstanding results. Sydney and Sue's expertise and attention to detail transformed our property into a true masterpiece of luxury living on Fire Island. Their respect for both us and our property was evident in every interaction, ensuring that our home was showcased in its best light. Communication was seamless throughout the entire process, with constant contact and swift responses to any concerns or queries we had. Sydney, Sue, and their team's professionalism and dedication made us feel supported and valued every step of the way.”

“After my listing expired with another local agent, I was disheartened and puzzled as to why my home wasn't attracting buyers. Skepticism clouded my thoughts about entrusting another agent. However, meeting Sue changed everything. Sue's approach was refreshingly different. She outlined a comprehensive marketing plan, emphasizing strategies like one-hour open houses and professional photography. Sue's expertise and dedication were evident from the start. Her innovative marketing tactics breathed new life into my listing, attracting a flurry of interested buyers. Before I knew it, my home was off the market, and sold at lightning speed. This experience reaffirmed the importance of choosing the right realtor.”

“What truly impressed us with working with Luxury Fire Island Homes was their ability to deliver results beyond our expectations. Despite being told our house would sell in a month, they managed to secure a buyer in just three weeks! This remarkable achievement speaks volumes about their expertise and commitment to excellence. We highly recommend Sydney, Sue, and Luxury Fire Island Homes to anyone looking to buy or sell a property. Their dedication, professionalism, and proven track record make them the ultimate choice for luxury real estate on Fire Island.”

“Working with Sydney and Sue at Luxury Fire Island Homes was fantastic. Their top-notch service and constant communication made the selling process stress-free. They were always available to address any questions or concerns promptly. Sydney and Sue's professionalism and expertise exceeded our expectations. When we're ready to sell our other property, they'll be our first call. Thanks to Sydney, Sue, and the Luxury Fire Island Homes team for another successful sale!”

“Working with Sydney and Sue McCoy at Luxury Fire Island Homes was an absolute pleasure! Their expertise and guidance in a competitive market made the home-buying process seamless. They helped us find the perfect beach home for our family. I highly recommend them to anyone in need of real estate services. Thank you to Sydney, Sue, and the Luxury Fire Island Homes team for their outstanding support!”

“Feeling puzzled about why my home wasn't selling, I turned to Sydney and Sue at Luxury Fire Island Homes. Their innovative marketing plan, complete with a one-hour open house and stunning professional photography, completely transformed the game! Working with the right realtors is key, and Sydney and Sue proved just that. Thank you for everything!”

“After a disappointing experience with a previous realtor, I was hesitant to seek professional help again. But Sydney and Sue at Luxury Fire Island Homes changed my perspective entirely. They showed me how partnering with them could lead to a higher profit margin. Despite my initial reservations, their guidance proved invaluable. I'm thrilled with the outcome and grateful for their unwavering support. Sydney and Sue, you're the only realtors I'll ever rely on.”

“I needed to sell my home fast and I wanted to work with someone local. Susan McCoy with Luxury Fire Island Homes ended up getting me 3 cash offers within 5 minutes of calling her office. I was shocked and I accepted on the spot. IT was such a pleasant experience. I didn’t have to worry about cleaning up my house or showings.. And I even got to pick my closing date. I could not recommend with working with this great team more!!”

“Just a quick review to say how pleased we were working with Sydney and Susan in the sale of our beach house at Fire Island in February. The women were wonderful to work with, very professional every step of the way and did everything in their power to stay accessible and helpful. They were extremely attentive to our family’s needs in this sale and made the process pleasant and stress-free. They took the stress out of what could have been a very stressful process and we truly appreciated their knowledge and professionalism.”